Distillation is not enough

From Issawiki
Jump to: navigation, search

I think there's a somewhat popular meme in some rationalist circles that goes something like: "To make intellectual progress, we just need to create a space where people can propose lots of ideas rapidly, not worrying about the quality so much. Then, we can come back and organize all of the good stuff into a distilled form." This leads to things like LessWrong shortform, LessWrong annual review, blog posts like babble and prune, and so on.

I think the two parts of this meme are important, but I think on their own they are not enough, so I feel like extending this to include more things like exercises, spaced repetition, asynchronous support, etc.

Returning to this almost a year later, I'm not entirely sure what I was thinking. I think even just posting poorly-written ideas is sufficient to make intellectual progress (as long as the ideas are good). That's what we had for most of human history. I guess it would be nice if making intellectual progress was also really fun and efficient and not frustrating, and that's where the other stuff comes in. But how do we trade off between just pushing forward vs explaining things more clearly and providing support?