Page
ReadView sourceView history

Narrow vs broad cognitive augmentation

From Issawiki (static archive)

Here is one axis I've been paying attention to when thinking about the question of "how to do we make people better at thinking?":

Finding a broad augmentation allows you to "unlock" a new ability that applies to everything you want to learn or think about, but it's also "shallow" in the sense that the augmentation itself does not "talk about" or "know about" any specific topic you want to learn about.

A narrow augmentation is more satisfying to use, but inventing it still takes a lot of work and you must invent separate tools for every topic you want to think about.

The kind of visualization work that 3blue1brown does feels like kind of a mix. On one hand, visualization itself feels like a broad augmentation. But on the other hand, Grant has to create a separate video for each thing he wants to explain. The audience doesn't know how to animate math concepts; they are just there to consume. So it's narrow too in that sense.

Andy Matuschak talks about a similar distinction in "We can develop the mnemonic medium by writing about topics with only moderate domain expertise".[1] In particular see quotes like, "If you’re developing an interface that gets its power by reifying deep ideas about a medium (like Logo), you need deep expertise in that medium to reify the right ideas. Papert didn’t have that. By contrast, the mnemonic medium primarily reifies ideas about memory, theory of knowledge, habits, etc—not ideas about quantum computing."

See also

What links here

References